Comparing Roofing Materials: Which Is Best for Your Minnesota Home?

Living in Minnesota means dealing with a unique climate—frigid winters, heavy snowfall, spring storms, and humid summers. Your home’s roof is its first line of defense against these elements, which makes choosing the right roofing material an essential decision for homeowners.

With so many options available, it can feel overwhelming to decide what type of roof is best for your home. Should you go for asphalt shingles? Maybe metal roofing? Or what about cedar shakes? Each material has its pros and cons, and in this guide, we’ll break them down to help you make the best choice.

1. Asphalt Shingles: The Affordable and Reliable Choice

Pros:

Budget-Friendly – Asphalt shingles are one of the most cost-effective roofing materials on the market, making them a popular choice for homeowners.
Easy to Install & Repair – If a shingle gets damaged, replacing it is relatively simple.
Variety of Styles and Colors – Whether you prefer a traditional or modern look, asphalt shingles come in various colors and textures to complement your home’s aesthetic.
Good Durability – Modern asphalt shingles are designed to withstand strong winds and moderate hail impact.

Cons:

Lifespan – Asphalt shingles typically last between 15 to 30 years, which is shorter than some other roofing materials.
Vulnerability to Extreme Weather – While they hold up well in most conditions, heavy snow and ice buildup can shorten their lifespan.
Environmental Impact – Since asphalt shingles need to be replaced more frequently than metal or slate roofing, they contribute more to landfill waste.

Best For:

If you’re looking for a balance between affordability, style, and performance, asphalt shingles are a solid choice for Minnesota homeowners.

2. Metal Roofing: The Durable and Energy-Efficient Option

Pros:

Long Lifespan – Metal roofs can last 40–70 years, depending on the material.
Excellent for Snow and Ice – Metal roofing naturally sheds snow and ice, reducing the risk of ice dams in winter.
Energy Efficient – Reflects sunlight, reducing cooling costs in the summer.
Highly Durable – Resistant to wind, hail, and fire, making it a great choice for Minnesota’s severe weather conditions.
Eco-Friendly – Many metal roofs are made from recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their lifespan.

Cons:

Higher Upfront Cost – While it lasts longer, metal roofing has a higher initial investment compared to asphalt shingles.
Noise Factor – Rain and hail can be noisier on a metal roof unless proper insulation is installed.
Denting – While most modern metal roofing is designed to resist impact, extreme hail can sometimes cause dents.

Best For:

Homeowners looking for a long-lasting, energy-efficient, and low-maintenance roofing option—especially those concerned about heavy snowfall and extreme weather.

3. Cedar Shakes: A Natural, Rustic Aesthetic

Pros:

Timeless Beauty – Cedar shakes provide a classic, rustic look that many homeowners love.
Natural Insulation – Cedar naturally helps regulate indoor temperatures, keeping homes warmer in winter and cooler in summer.
Eco-Friendly – Biodegradable and sourced from renewable materials.

Cons:

High Maintenance – Requires regular treatment to prevent moss, mold, and rot.
Fire Risk – Wood is naturally flammable, though fire-resistant treatments are available.
Shorter Lifespan Compared to Metal or Slate – Typically lasts around 20-30 years with proper maintenance.
Higher Cost – More expensive than asphalt shingles and requires professional installation.

Best For:

Homeowners who prioritize aesthetics and are willing to invest in routine maintenance to preserve their roof’s beauty and longevity.

4. Slate Roofing: The Luxury, Long-Lasting Investment

Pros:

Extremely Long Lifespan – Can last 75-100+ years, making it one of the most durable options available.
Resistant to Fire, Mold, and Rot – Slate is naturally impervious to many of the elements that degrade other roofing materials.
Low Maintenance – Unlike cedar, slate doesn’t require regular treatment.
Timeless Elegance – Adds a sophisticated look to any home.

Cons:

High Cost – One of the most expensive roofing materials due to both the material and specialized installation.
Heavy Weight – Requires a structurally sound home to support its weight.
Difficult Repairs – If a slate tile breaks, replacing it can be a challenge since matching tiles can be tricky.

Best For:

Homeowners looking for a long-term investment and those with historic or high-end homes who want an elegant, nearly maintenance-free roofing option.

5. Composite Roofing: The Best of Both Worlds

Pros:

Mimics Natural Materials – Composite shingles can look like slate, cedar, or traditional shingles but with added durability.
Lightweight – Unlike real slate, composite roofing won’t strain your home’s structure.
Durable & Long-Lasting – Many composite materials are engineered to last 40–50 years.
Low Maintenance – Resistant to rot, mold, and mildew.
Eco-Friendly Options Available – Some composite roofs are made from recycled materials.

Cons:

Cost – While not as expensive as slate, composite roofing can be pricier than asphalt shingles.
Limited Availability – Some high-quality composite brands can be harder to find locally.

Best For:

Homeowners who want a durable, stylish, and low-maintenance roof without the high cost of slate or the upkeep of cedar.

Final Thoughts: What’s the Best Choice for Your Minnesota Home?

Choosing the right roofing material depends on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and long-term goals. Here’s a quick summary:

On a Budget? Asphalt shingles are your best bet.
Want Longevity & Durability? Metal or slate roofing is a great investment.
Love the Rustic Look? Cedar shakes add natural charm.
Looking for a Middle Ground? Composite roofing offers durability with aesthetic flexibility.

No matter what roofing material you choose, working with a trusted roofing contractor is key to ensuring proper installation and maximizing your investment.

Need Help Deciding? At Midwest Exteriors MN, we specialize in helping homeowners find the best roofing solutions for their needs. Contact us today for a free consultation and let’s protect your home for years to come!

‍